Will participating insurance's non-guaranteed returns deliver?
The returns of participating (savings) insurance usually split into a guaranteed and a non-guaranteed part. By definition the non-guaranteed part is not certain; the projected figures in an illustration are “expected”, not promised, and whether they are met depends on the insurer's investment performance. This is not to say participating insurance is bad — only that you should understand what the numbers mean.
Will the non-guaranteed return meet the projection?
Not necessarily. Non-guaranteed means, by definition, not guaranteed; the projected dividends in an illustration are estimates, not a contractual promise. Actual payouts may be higher, equal to or lower than projected, depending on the insurer's actual investment returns and operations.
So when comparing policies, don't look only at the projected total return — pay attention to how much is guaranteed versus non-guaranteed.
What is the fulfilment ratio?
The fulfilment ratio is a disclosed metric showing actual dividends paid relative to what the original illustration projected. 100% means projections were met; below 100% means actual was less than projected.
Hong Kong's Insurance Authority requires insurers to disclose fulfilment ratios for participating policies; you can check them on the insurer's website as a guide to how well it has delivered on projections.
Fulfilment ratios reflect past performance, which does not indicate future results; ratios vary by product and year.
What to consider when evaluating
- Guaranteed vs non-guaranteed split: the higher the guaranteed part, the more certainty.
- Fulfilment-ratio track record: how well the insurer has met projections.
- Your goal: certain cash flow, or accepting more uncertainty for potentially higher returns.
- Liquidity and term: early surrender usually incurs a loss — match it to your cash needs.
Are there other options?
No product is universally “better”. If you value certainty, products with a higher guaranteed component or an annuity may fit better; if you can bear uncertainty for potentially higher returns, participating policies or other investments each have a role. The key is to be clear on your goals and risk tolerance first, then compare.
General education only, not insurance, investment or financial advice, nor a recommendation or rating of any product. Consult a licensed insurance intermediary before deciding, and rely on the policy terms and the insurer's disclosures.
Related reading
Frequently asked questions
Can I trust the projected returns in an illustration?
Projected returns are estimates based on assumptions — useful for reference, not a promise. Also look at the guaranteed portion and the insurer's fulfilment-ratio track record for a fuller picture.
Where can I check the fulfilment ratio?
Hong Kong's Insurance Authority requires insurers to disclose fulfilment ratios for participating policies; they are usually on each insurer's official website. Note that past performance does not indicate the future.
Is participating insurance simply bad?
No. It has its role; the question is not good or bad, but whether it fits your goals and risk tolerance, and whether you understand the guaranteed versus non-guaranteed split.
Book a retirement planning consultation
An advisor helps you integrate MPF, annuities, insurance and cash flow.